The under/overrated thread past and present players

[Goodfellas]

Overrated - Tony Romo
Underrated - Ben Roethlisberger

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Ray Lewis
Underrated James Harrison

[Goodfellas]

Ovverrated Alex Rodriguez
Underrated - Mike Lowell

[Goodfellas]

overrated don mattingly
underrated Todd Helton

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Joe DiMaggio
Underrated Mickey Mantle

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Orlando Cepeda
Underrated Willie McCovey

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Carlton Fisk
/underrated Mike Piazza

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Greg oden
Underrated Kevin Durant

[bringingthehuge]

Overrated: Carmello Anthony
Underrated: Paul Pierce

[Goodfellas]

Overrated: Carmello Anthony
Underrated: Paul Pierce


Good one even though I am 5 mins from Syracuse Univ

[Goodfellas]

overrated bill russell
underrated wilt chamberlain

[bringingthehuge]

Overrated: Albert Haynesworth
Underrated: Richard Seymore

[Goodfellas]

overrated jorge posada
underrated joe mauer

[bringingthehuge]

Good one even though I am 5 mins from Syracuse Univ
Not a big Syracuse fan I like Uconn. But the Orangemen are usually pretty tough.

[Goodfellas]

overrated david ortiz
underrated justin morneau

[bringingthehuge]

overrated bill russell
underrated wilt chamberlain
Bill Russel wasn't an extremely dominant player but you can't argue with 11 championships.

[Goodfellas]

overrated matt leinart
underrated joe flacco

[bringingthehuge]

overrated david ortiz
underrated justin morneau
I agree

[Goodfellas]

Bill Russel wasn't an extremely dominant player but you can't argue with 11 championships.

my argument was russell's team had 9 or 10 teammates make the hall of fame, Wilt did not have that supporting cast...

[bringingthehuge]

overrated: Ladanian Tomilson
underrated: Frank Gore

[Goodfellas]

overrated cc sabathia
underrated roy halliday

[Goodfellas]

overrated reggie bush
underrated brian westbrook

[bringingthehuge]

overrated: Terrell Owens
underrated: Roddy White

[Goodfellas]

overrated larry johnson
underrated brandon jacobs

[Goodfellas]

overrated doug williams
underrated phil simms

[bringingthehuge]

Overrated: AJ Burnett
Underrated: Cliff Lee

[Goodfellas]

overrated jeremy shockey
underrated tony gonzalez

[Goodfellas]

overrated jason kidd
underrated chris paul

[Goodfellas]

overrated ricky williams
underrated tiki barber

[Goodfellas]

underrated jim thome
overrated mark McGwire

[Goodfellas]

overrated tracy mcgrady
underrated ray allen

[Goodfellas]

overrated luis castillo
underrated robinson cano

[Goodfellas]

overrated Yankees
underrated Red sox

[Goodfellas]

overrated dale jr
underrated kyle busch

[bringingthehuge]

Overrated:Stephan Marbury
Underrated: Rafer Alston ( skip to my lou )

[The Big Sexy]

overrated - Dwight Howard
underrated - Ben Gordon

[bringingthehuge]

Overrated: Jermaine Oneal
underrated: Omeka Okafor

[Goodfellas]

overrated chris duhon
underrated nate robinson

[Goodfellas]

Overrated santana moss
underrated wes welker

[Goodfellas]

overrrated chad johnson
underrated hines ward

[bringingthehuge]

overrated: Darren Woodson
underrated: Cory Webster

[Goodfellas]

overrated Jonathan Vilma
underrated Bart Scott

[Goodfellas]

overrated Huston Street
underrated Carlos Marmol

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Marc Bulger
Underrated Chad Pennington

[Goodfellas]

underrated Ed Reed
underrated Troy Polamalu

[Goodfellas]

Underrrated Alfonso Soriano
Overrated Jason Bay

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Max Afinoganov
Underrated Jason Pominville

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Dikembe Mutombo
Underrated Alonzo Mourning

[Goodfellas]

Underrated Marion Barber
Overrated Thomas Jones

[Goodfellas]

overrated chris osgood
underrated Marc Andre Fleury

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Jay Cutler
Underrated Phillip Rivers

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Jackie Robinson
Underrated Roberto Clemente

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Martin Biron
Underrated Ryan Miller

[bringingthehuge]

Overrated: Jack Dempsey
Underrated: Gene Tunney

[bringingthehuge]

overrated: Antwan Walker
underrated: Kendrick Perkins

[razorsedge]

Overrated: Kobe
Underrated: Michael Jordan
Magic Johnson
Larry Bird
Kevin Garnett
D. Wade
LeBron James, etc.

[razorsedge]

Overrated: Brian Urlacher
Underrated: Lance Briggs

[Goodfellas]

Underrated Tim Duncan
Overrated Yao

[Goodfellas]

Overrated: Brian Urlacher
Underrated: Lance Briggs

Good one!

[Goodfellas]

overrated charlie weiss
underrated gary pinkel

[Goodfellas]

overrated sam bradford
underrated colt McCoy

[Goodfellas]

overrated matt hasselback
underrated drew brees

[Goodfellas]

oveerrated roger goodell
underrated david stern

[Goodfellas]

overrated alex ovechkin
underrated sidney crosby

[Goodfellas]

overrated chris chelios
underrated ray bourque

[Goodfellas]

overrrated brad childress
underrated jeff fisher

[Goodfellas]

overrated Jim Calhoun
underrated Jim Boeheim :D:D:D:D:D

[Goodfellas]

overrated satchell page
underrated Cy Young

[Goodfellas]

overrated Charles Barkley
underrated Karl Malone

[Goodfellas]

overrated steve nash
underrated john stockton

[Goodfellas]

underrated Pete Maravich
underrated Pete Maravich

[Goodfellas]

overrated Wade Phillips
underrated Tom Coughlin

[Goodfellas]

overrated micky ward
underrated Arturo Gotti

[Goodfellas]

overrated AJ Burnett
Underrated Tim Lincecum

[Goodfellas]

overrated chien min Wang
underrated Tim Wakefield

[Goodfellas]

overrated Sean avery
underrated Thomas Vanek

[Goodfellas]

overrated eric mangini
underrated bill bellichek

[Goodfellas]

overrated Arod
underrated Evan Longoria

[Goodfellas]

overrated vince young
underrated kerry collins

[Goodfellas]

overrated LenDale White
underrated Darren McFadden

[Goodfellas]

overrated Kyle Orton
underrated Jason Campbell

[Goodfellas]

overrated carlton fisk
underrated johnny bench

[razorsedge]

Overrated: Lou Piniella
Underrated: Dusty Baker.

[Steve56]

Overrated Joe DiMaggio
Underrated Mickey Mantle


Joe D overrated....are u crazy??

He lost 4 years to the war and still hit 360 hrs in a balpark that was not conducive to right handed hitters...if he played in fenway he would have hit over 500 hrs....in 1941 he hit .357 and only struck out 13 times in 540 at bats just think about that for a while!!

[Goodfellas]

Joe D overrated....are u crazy??

He lost 4 years to the war and still hit 360 hrs in a balpark that was not conducive to right handed hitters...if he played in fenway he would have hit over 500 hrs....in 1941 he hit .357 and only struck out 13 times in 540 at bats just think about that for a while!!

Mantle lost years off his career due to injuries and it was cut short.

Overrated compared tto mantle.

And yeah maybe I am a little crazy.

[exit2010]

overrated Ohio State football
underrated Oregon football

[exit2010]

overrated Chris Cormier
underrated Mike Francois

[exit2010]

overrated Lebron James
underrated Kevin Garnett

[exit2010]

overrated New York Yankees
underrated St. Louis Cardinals

[exit2010]

overrated New England Patriots
underrated Philadelphia Eagles

[Goodfellas]

overrated Lebron James
underrated Kevin Garnett

I thought I was the only one that disliked him :)

[exit2010]

If he was great then he could lead his team as well. He is an outstanding player not a leader.

[exit2010]

Underrated Allison Moyer

http://modelmayhm-9.vo.llnwd.net/d1/photos/080904/10/48bfeefc9be26_m.jpg

[bringingthehuge]

overrated Jim Calhoun
underrated Jim Boeheim :D:D:D:D:D
thats a low blow

[exit2010]

overrated Coco
http://celebpulp.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/coco_ice_t1.jpg

[razorsedge]

Overrated: Big Ten
Underrated: the MAC!:bowdown:

[exit2010]

The MAC? Seriously? Okay.

underrated Donovan McNabb
overrated Philip Rivers

[Goodfellas]

thats a low blow

Calhoun has a better record against Boeheim doesn't he?

[razorsedge]

College Football Conferences: Overrated: Big East.
Underrated: Mountain West.
MLB Players: Overrated: Sammy Sosa
Underrated: Ken Griffey, jr.

[Goodfellas]

College Football Conferences: Overrated: Big East.
Underrated: Mountain West.
MLB Players: Overrated: Sammy Sosa
Underrated: Ken Griffey, jr.

Big East Football should be knocked down a division.

[exit2010]

I thought I was the only one that disliked him :)


Shaq just joined the Cavs from Phoenix.

Underrated Cleveland Cavaliers
Overrated Miami Heaat

[exit2010]

Underrated American World Cup Soccer team
Overrated German World Cup team

[exit2010]

underrated la cosa nostra
overrated ms13

[bringingthehuge]

Calhoun has a better record against Boeheim doesn't he?
I'm not sure but i know Calhoun has more wins, big east titles and national championships. There both good coaches and have very similar careers

[bringingthehuge]

Big East Football should be knocked down a division.
Uconn is on the rise

[Goodfellas]

Uconn is on the rise

Join the Big Ten....

[bringingthehuge]

The two best big east football programs left for the ACC

[Goodfellas]

The two best big east football programs left for the ACC

Yeah they are talking about starting Greg Paulus here the team is so bad.

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Big 10
Underrated ACC

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Nate Robinson
Underrated Pau Gasol

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Mike Vrabel
Underrated James Harrrison

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Brett Favre
Underrated Kerry Collins

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Roy Williams safety
Underrated Brian Dawkins

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Roy Williams WR
Underrated Lee Evans

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Adam Dunn
Underrated Mark Teixiera

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Emmitt Smith
Underrated Barry Sanders

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Dre Bly
Underrated Champ Bailey

[razorsedge]

Overrated: Derek Lee & Carlos Zambrano
Underrated: Jermaine Dye & John Danks

[Goodfellas]

Good one. Lee is always hurt and Zambrano is a jerk.

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Citi Field
Underrrated Shea Stadium

[Goodfellas]

Overrated Jason Taylor
Underrated Lee Suggs

[bringingthehuge]

overrated: Adam Vinatieri
underrated: Stephen Gostkowski

[Goodfellas]

overrated casey hampton
underrated vince wilfolk

[Goodfellas]

underrated chris johnson
overrated larry johnson

[exit2010]

overrated Cover 2 defense
underrated 4-3 defense

[exit2010]

overrated Jon Gruden
underrated Marty Schottenheimer

[exit2010]

overrated Eric Mangini
underrated Lovie Smith

[exit2010]

overrated San Diego Chargers
underrated New York Jets

[Bigboi]

Wow, there some strange choice here. Anyway, heres mine
LT= overated
Adrian peterson=underated.

[Goodfellas]

We are just having fun no right or wrong answers

[Goodfellas]

overrrated Thomas Jones
underrated Eddie George

[cook]

I was at the Cowboys pro shop at Texas stadium last year looking through some jerseys and they had an Eddie George Cowboy jersey for 120$ Now Eddie had a great career but how many people even remember he played for Dallas?

[Goodfellas]

$120 maybe $20 I would pay...

[dallas3]

Overrated: Plaxico Burress
Underrated: Andre Johnson

[Goodfellas]

overrated Joba
underrated Jon Lester