2016 IFBB New York Pro LIVE Play by Play with Palumbo & Aceto, Plus Photos and Video

**Geoff Roberts** · 05-22-2016, 12:41 AM

Originally Posted by MusclePoppins

I had Michelle Sylvia ahead of Victor.

drevil_cover.jpg

**Geoff Roberts** · 05-22-2016, 12:48 AM

Originally Posted by joe-ali

You have ur favorites I am just be objective. I look for flaws and in pics Vic condition looks subpar compared to Maxx, Steve, and Nathan. Bodybuilding is about judging who has least flaws not who is most popular or who ur favorite is.

I do not understand Vics high placings. I mean, the guy is an awesome dude, but his waist is not good. It is not small by any stretch and its looks distracting. I do not understand why people go on and on about his shape. His legs do not match his upper body, his arms look jimmied up (although most of the top guys at this show looked jimmied up somewhere), and his back, which used to be his best body part, is way down in size. .

**Big Beat** · 05-22-2016, 01:38 AM

From the pre judging photos I didn't see Roelly as 2nd. He didn't seems as tight as the Body Power and while massive his aesthetics do not match the other Top 5.

Kuclo looked a bit better than 5th to me, he looked huge in the photos. Still it's hard to judge when you are not at the show.

**JohnnyStyles** · 05-22-2016, 04:07 AM

Roelly in person tonight was jaw dropping ....

uploading final wrap up #TeamNoSleep

**JohnnyStyles** · 05-22-2016, 04:35 AM

**davidcua** · 05-22-2016, 05:37 AM

Originally Posted by huge285

MENS BODYBUILDING FINALS 1st CALLOUT

ROELLY WINKLAAR
MAXX CHARLES
DEXTER JACKSON
STEVE KUCLO
VICTOR MARTINEZ
JUAN MOREL

**** I have ROELLY 1st, DEXTER 2nd, MAXX CHARLES 3rd
.......ROELLY is a freak.....and just bigger than DEXTER even though DEXTER is sharper..

LOL your placing was my exact prediction before the shows. And obviously it would have been the right outcome !